Raffles Consulting Services
VCC sub-fund expense allocation should follow who incurred and benefited from each cost, with a documented method for shared umbrella expenses.
VCC sub-fund expense allocation should start with the legal purpose of each cost. Charge a liability to the sub-fund that incurred it. For shared umbrella costs, use a written method that reflects the benefit or work received, apply it consistently and keep enough evidence to repeat the calculation.
A convenient split is not enough. The accounting record, contract, invoice, payment and fund documents should all support the same sub-fund treatment. This is especially important when one administrator invoice covers several strategies.
Start with the statutory segregation rule
Section 29 of the Variable Capital Companies Act 2018 protects the separation of sub-fund assets and liabilities. A liability incurred for one sub-fund must be discharged only from that sub-fund’s assets. Its assets cannot discharge another sub-fund’s liabilities or the umbrella’s unrelated liabilities.
Section 19 also implies in every umbrella VCC constitution that assets and liabilities must be allocated and used in line with section 29. Therefore, an expense policy should not sit apart from the constitution and offering documents. It should help the board, manager and administrator apply them in daily records.
The statutory protection does not choose an allocation key for every shared invoice. The VCC still needs a reasonable method grounded in the actual service, mandate and contractual arrangements.
Identify direct costs before allocating shared costs
Direct costs usually have a clear owner. Examples include brokerage for one portfolio, legal work for one asset purchase, a valuation for one holding and a sub-fund-specific regulatory filing. Post those costs directly when the contract and invoice support the attribution.
Do not put all expenses into an umbrella account and divide them at year end. That approach can hide errors for months. Instead, require purchase requests, engagement letters and invoices to carry the sub-fund name or an approved umbrella code from the start.
Section 30 requires an umbrella VCC to identify the sub-fund and its registration number in agreements, invoices, receipts and other documents where a sub-fund is mentioned. The document must also state that the assets and liabilities are segregated. This disclosure supports clean contracting and later allocation.
Choose a sensible key for each shared service
| Shared cost | Possible allocation basis | Reason to test |
|---|---|---|
| Fund administration | Transaction count, NAV workload or agreed fee schedule | AUM alone may ignore operational complexity |
| Audit | Engagement scope, entity work and sub-fund testing hours | New or complex sub-funds may require more work |
| Directors and company secretary | Fixed umbrella portion plus sub-fund activity | Duties can serve both entity and portfolio matters |
| Insurance | Coverage, risk exposure or insured value | Not every policy protects each sub-fund equally |
| Data and systems | User count, portfolio count, licence use or transaction volume | Flat splits can shift costs between investor groups |
| General legal work | Recorded matter time and beneficiary | The legal question may concern only one mandate |
No single key works for every service. AUM may be reasonable for custody or some administration costs. It may be poor for a lightly capitalised sub-fund with many trades. In practice, the policy should name the default key and the facts that justify an exception.
Use information available at the allocation date. If the method uses average NAV, define the period and source. If it uses transactions, define what counts as one transaction. Keep the calculation and reviewer approval with the invoice.
Decide how the umbrella bears its own costs
Some costs relate to the umbrella VCC as a legal entity rather than one sub-fund. Examples may include the core registered-office service, entity-level filings or a board matter that serves the umbrella generally. The fund documents and applicable accounting treatment should determine whether the umbrella retains the cost or allocates it.
Do not push every umbrella cost to the largest sub-fund because it can absorb it. That can transfer value between investors. Equally, an equal split can be unfair when only one sub-fund caused extra work.
For example, an umbrella has three sub-funds. Two use standard listed-equity strategies, while the third launches a private-credit strategy that needs extra legal review. The base governance cost may follow the normal umbrella method. The private-credit legal work should go directly to the third sub-fund when the engagement and invoice identify that work.
Control payments and reimbursements
Where possible, pay a sub-fund liability from the account maintained for that sub-fund. If the umbrella or another account temporarily pays it, record a clear payable and reimbursement. Do not leave unexplained inter-fund balances.
Make a monthly exception report for invoices without a sub-fund code, manual journals, old inter-fund balances and changes to allocation keys. The administrator should resolve exceptions before NAV sign-off. The manager and board should see material or repeated issues.
In addition, check the tax character and GST treatment using the same factual allocation. A bookkeeping split does not decide whether an expense is deductible or recoverable. Obtain tax advice where the treatment is material.
Write a policy that staff can apply
The policy should list direct-cost rules, approved shared-cost keys, data sources, review frequency, rounding, materiality and exception authority. It should also state who can create a new allocation basis and who checks it.
Keep a register with the vendor, invoice, service period, gross amount, tax, direct portion, shared portion, allocation key, sub-fund result and reviewer. This creates a repeatable audit trail without turning every small invoice into a board paper.
ACRA’s post-registration guidance covers sub-fund registration and continuing VCC matters. The allocation record should use the registered sub-fund names and numbers shown in the current register.
Link expense records to wider VCC governance
The VCC launch-readiness guide is the pillar cornerstone. The umbrella sub-fund guide explains registration and ring-fencing, while the valuation-governance guide covers NAV controls. The Funds, VCCs and Cross-Border Structures hub lists related guidance.
Good allocation is visible in ordinary records. A reviewer should be able to start with an invoice, identify the benefiting sub-fund, reproduce any shared calculation and trace the final payment without guessing.